Scored using Vacuum Cleaners Methodology v3.0
Vacuum Cleaners Methodology v3.0
Mathematical & Unbiased Scoring
Products in this category are scored under Frontum Vacuum Cleaners Methodology v3.0: the technical score from the specifications is the base, and independent expert and video reviews (up to ±0.5 points), owner opinions (up to ±0.3) and best-of lists (up to +0.3) move it up or down.
Explore Vacuum Cleaners Methodology v3.0

Miele Guard S1 Review: 53 Specs Compared

Avg. price:~$330Suction power (AW):?Battery runtime:N/A minutesCapacity:118 fl ozWeight:12.3 lb

Miele Guard S1 Review: Compare 53 technical specifications, 6 expert and video reviews and 1 best-of list to see how this product ranks in the Vacuum Cleaners category and whether it is worth buying.

Miele Guard S1
6.8/10

Overall score

Score
6.8/ 10
✕
What it is
Our main score for this model, 1–10. It combines specs, best-of lists, expert reviews and owners.
How we count it
Parts: Technical score 35%, List score 30%, Reviews score 25%, Sentiment score 10%
Marks: Each part gets a mark out of 10. For reviews, lists and owners, a typical model in this category gets about 8 and the best one gets 10.
No data yet: A part with no data shows "?". It counts as the mark of a weaker model in this category (4 in 5 models with data score higher). This way, models with reviews, lists and owners usually come out ahead.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Score components

35%

6.2

Technical Score

30%

8.1

List score

25%

6.2

Reviews score

10%

?

Sentiment scoreNot enough data yet, so we use 6.8, the mark of a weaker model in this category

▼Worse than 74% of vacuum cleaners
7.4

Ratio quality/price

Ratio quality/price
7.4/ 10
✕
What it is
An indicator that combines the vacuum cleaner's overall score with its price.
When it matters
When you are looking for a vacuum cleaner with a good balance between quality and price.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Score components

70%

6.8

Overall score

30%

8.8

Price

▼Worse than 81%
6.2

Technical Score

Technical score
6.2/ 10
✕
What it is
How good the specs are compared with the other models in this category, 1–10.
How we count it
Areas: We rate the specs in each area against the other models in this category.
Weighting: The areas that matter most to buyers count more. The shares are shown under Score components.
Share: The technical score is 35% of the overall score.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Score components

28%

7.0

Performance

22%

4.4

Battery

18%

7.5

Filtration

14%

7.9

Attachments

10%

4.8

Design

8%

4.0

Smart features

▼Worse than 66%
6.2

Reviews score

Reviews score
6.2/ 10
✕
What it is
Average grade from independent test sites, magazines and video reviewers, 1–10.
How we count it
Grades: Each review's own score is converted to 1–10; without one, we grade the review ourselves. Big test sites count more, short reviews half as much as full tests. A video review counts half.
Score: The average grade is 80% of the review mark; the number of reviews is the other 20% (1 review = 5, the typical number in this category = 8, the most-reviewed model = 10).
Enough data: With few reviews, the average grade is pulled toward the typical grade of this category. No reviews yet: 7.6 for now.
Share: Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10

6.2

Mark 7.5 is below the typical mark 8.1 of this category, so it cannot lift the score above the technical score

80%

7.4

Average grade

20%

8.2

Popularity

Grades by review (6)
5 reviews: 1 with a printed score, 4 estimated from the review. 1 video review, counting half as much as a written test. Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
User ratings collected online are not part of this score.
▼Worse than 80%
?

Sentiment score

Sentiment score
6.8/ 10
✕
What it is
How positive owners are about this model in their comments under video reviews and on forums. We read each comment, keep only people who say they own the model, and sort them into positive, mixed or negative.
How we count it
Score: We compare how satisfied this model’s owners are with the other models in this category: the typical model gets 8, the most satisfied tenth 10, the least satisfied 4. This is 80% of the owner mark; the number of owners is the other 20%.
Enough data: A model counts with 10+ owners from 4+ different discussions. With fewer, the owner part counts as 6.8 for now.
Share: Owners count 10% of the overall score (left out in categories where fewer than 10 models have enough owner comments).
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Owners (1)
Not enough owner comments yet (10+ owners from 4+ discussions needed), so the owner part counts as 6.8 for now.
Our own analysis of online owner opinions, not a rating from any website.
Not enough owner comments yet
8.1

List score

List score
8.1/ 10
✕
What it is
How often independent test sites, magazines and video reviewers put this model in their best-of lists for this category.
How we count it
Points: The model in the most lists of this category gets 10; the others get 8 to 10 in proportion. In no list yet: 7.5. Lists count 30% of the overall score.
Enough data: Every list counts, even a single one. With fewer than 5 best-of lists in the category, this part is left out.
Lists with this model (1)
List score: in 1 of 64 lists (2%)
▼Worse than 52%
  • miele-guard-s1
miele-guard-s1
Where to Buy
*As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

What Reviewers Say About the Miele Guard S1

Based on 4 · 1

Reviewers like the adjustable power and handy attachments, but most are disappointed by its cleaning results.
Praised
Criticised
Pick a topic to see who said what
Loading...
Loading category ranking...

Technical Specifications of Vacuum Cleaner Miele Guard S1

Technical Score
Technical score
6.2/ 10
✕
What it is
How good the specs are compared with the other models in this category, 1–10.
How we count it
Areas: We rate the specs in each area against the other models in this category.
Weighting: The areas that matter most to buyers count more. The shares are shown under Score components.
Share: The technical score is 35% of the overall score.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Score components:

28%

7.0

Performance

22%

4.4

Battery

18%

7.5

Filtration

14%

7.9

Attachments

10%

4.8

Design

8%

4.0

Smart features

6.2
Reviews score
6.2
Sentiment score
?
List score
8.1
Ratio quality/price
Value for money
7.4/ 10
✕
What it is
An indicator that combines the vacuum cleaner's overall score with its price.
When it matters
When you are looking for a vacuum cleaner with a good balance between quality and price.
Score distribution
▼
<55-66-77-88-99-10
Score components:

70%

6.8

Overall score

30%

8.8

Price

7.4
Suction power (AW)
?
Suction power (kPa)
20.59 kPa
This vacuum cleaner has a suction pressure of 20.59 kPa, which is higher than that of 60.1% of vacuum cleaners.
Airflow
?
Motor type
powerline
Power consumption
890 W
This vacuum cleaner draws 890 W, which is higher than the power consumption of 86% of vacuum cleaners and equal to that of 2.6% of vacuum cleaners.
Show more
What reviewers say
Cordless
no
This vacuum cleaner does not work cordlessly. 49.5% of vacuum cleaners offer cordless operation.
Battery runtime
N/A
Charging time
N/A
Battery capacity
N/A
Battery voltage
N/A
Show more
Filter class
airclean
This vacuum cleaner uses filter class airclean, which is less advanced than the class used by 86.9% of vacuum cleaners and the same as the class used by 1.1% of vacuum cleaners.
Minimum overall efficiency
?
Suitable for allergy sufferers
yes
This vacuum cleaner is suitable for allergy sufferers. 82.4% of vacuum cleaners are allergy-friendly.
Capacity
118 fl oz
This vacuum cleaner has a dust capacity of 118 fl oz, which is larger than that of 85% of vacuum cleaners and equal to that of 4.5% of vacuum cleaners.
Bagless
no
This vacuum cleaner does not use a bagless design. 78.6% of vacuum cleaners use this setup.
Show more
Main brush type
classic
Roller type
none
Anti-tangle brush
no
This vacuum cleaner does not include an anti-tangle brush. 25.7% of vacuum cleaners include this feature.
Standard combo floorhead only.
Mini motorized brush
no
This vacuum cleaner does not include a mini motorized brush. 26.9% of vacuum cleaners include this attachment.
Suitable for pet owners
yes
This vacuum cleaner is suitable for pet owners. 72% of vacuum cleaners handle pet hair well.
Show more
What reviewers say
Vacuum type
canister
Weight
12.3 lb
This vacuum cleaner weighs 12.3 lb, which is greater than the weight of 76.6% of vacuum cleaners and equal to that of 1% of vacuum cleaners.
2-in-1 design
no
This vacuum cleaner does not offer a 2-in-1 design. 53% of vacuum cleaners offer this flexible format.
Self-standing
no
This vacuum cleaner does not stand on its own. 18.9% of vacuum cleaners offer this convenience.
Adjustable tube height
yes
This vacuum cleaner includes adjustable tube height. 47.4% of vacuum cleaners offer this ergonomic feature.
Show more
Auto suction adjustment
no
This vacuum cleaner does not support automatic suction adjustment. 19.9% of vacuum cleaners support this feature.
Dust particle sensor
no
This vacuum cleaner does not include a dust particle sensor. 8% of vacuum cleaners include this feature.
LED display
no
This vacuum cleaner does not include an LED display. 25.9% of vacuum cleaners include this interface feature.
Nozzle light
no
This vacuum cleaner does not include a nozzle light. 43.4% of vacuum cleaners include this visibility feature.
Mopping support
no
This vacuum cleaner does not support mopping. 3.7% of vacuum cleaners support this multi-function feature.

Miele Guard S1 vs the Average Vacuum Cleaner

246810TotalPerformanceBatteryFiltrationAttachmentsDesignSmart features
  • Includes parquet brush
    This vacuum cleaner includes a parquet brush, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • 2 more power levels
    This vacuum cleaner offers more speed levels than the average vacuum cleaner (4 vs 2).
    4 vs 2
  • Includes full bin indicator
    This vacuum cleaner includes a full bin indicator, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • 84 fl oz larger dust container
    This vacuum cleaner has a larger dust capacity than the average vacuum cleaner (118 fl oz vs 34 fl oz).
    118 fl oz vs 34 fl oz
  • Adjustable tube height
    This vacuum cleaner has adjustable tube height, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • Newer release date
    This vacuum cleaner has a newer release date than the average vacuum cleaner (2025 vs 2021).
    2025 vs 2021
  • 0.8 in wider cleaning path
    This vacuum cleaner has a wider cleaning path than the average vacuum cleaner (11 in vs 10.2 in).
    11 in vs 10.2 in
  • 3.3 ft longer power cord
    This vacuum cleaner has a longer power cord than the average vacuum cleaner (24.6 ft vs 21.3 ft).
    24.6 ft vs 21.3 ft
  • 5.2% higher list score
    List score
    8.1/ 10
    ✕
    What it is
    How often independent test sites, magazines and video reviewers put this model in their best-of lists for this category.
    How we count it
    Points: The model in the most lists of this category gets 10; the others get 8 to 10 in proportion. In no list yet: 7.5. Lists count 30% of the overall score.
    Enough data: Every list counts, even a single one. With fewer than 5 best-of lists in the category, this part is left out.
    Lists with this model (1)
    List score: in 1 of 64 lists (2%)
    8.1 vs 7.7
  • 2 more power levels
    This vacuum cleaner offers more speed levels than the average vacuum cleaner (4 vs 2).
    4 vs 2
  • Newer release date
    This vacuum cleaner has a newer release date than the average vacuum cleaner (2025 vs 2021).
    2025 vs 2021
  • 0.8 in wider cleaning path
    This vacuum cleaner has a wider cleaning path than the average vacuum cleaner (11 in vs 10.2 in).
    11 in vs 10.2 in
  • 0.59 kPa higher suction pressure
    This vacuum cleaner has higher suction pressure than the average vacuum cleaner (20.6 kPa vs 20 kPa).
    20.59 kPa vs 20 kPa
  • Quieter operation
    This vacuum cleaner is quieter than the average vacuum cleaner (75-76 dB vs 77-77 dB).
    75-76 dB vs 77-77 dB
  • 3.3 ft longer power cord
    This vacuum cleaner has a longer power cord than the average vacuum cleaner (24.6 ft vs 21.3 ft).
    24.6 ft vs 21.3 ft
  • Includes full bin indicator
    This vacuum cleaner includes a full bin indicator, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • 84 fl oz larger dust container
    This vacuum cleaner has a larger dust capacity than the average vacuum cleaner (118 fl oz vs 34 fl oz).
    118 fl oz vs 34 fl oz
  • Includes parquet brush
    This vacuum cleaner includes a parquet brush, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • Adjustable tube height
    This vacuum cleaner has adjustable tube height, the average vacuum cleaner does not.
  • No handheld conversion
    This vacuum cleaner does not have a 2-in-1 design, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • 53.8% higher weight
    This vacuum cleaner is heavier than the average vacuum cleaner (12.3 lb vs 8 lb).
    12.3 lb vs 8 lb
  • No bagless design
    This vacuum cleaner does not use a bagless design, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • No cyclonic technology
    This vacuum cleaner does not use cyclonic technology, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • No washable filter
    This vacuum cleaner does not include a washable filter, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • 16.2% lower review score
    Reviews score
    6.2/ 10
    ✕
    What it is
    Average grade from independent test sites, magazines and video reviewers, 1–10.
    How we count it
    Grades: Each review's own score is converted to 1–10; without one, we grade the review ourselves. Big test sites count more, short reviews half as much as full tests. A video review counts half.
    Score: The average grade is 80% of the review mark; the number of reviews is the other 20% (1 review = 5, the typical number in this category = 8, the most-reviewed model = 10).
    Enough data: With few reviews, the average grade is pulled toward the typical grade of this category. No reviews yet: 7.6 for now.
    Share: Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
    Score distribution
    ▼
    <55-66-77-88-99-10

    6.2

    Mark 7.5 is below the typical mark 8.1 of this category, so it cannot lift the score above the technical score

    80%

    7.4

    Average grade

    20%

    8.2

    Popularity

    Grades by review (6)
    5 reviews: 1 with a printed score, 4 estimated from the review. 1 video review, counting half as much as a written test. Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
    User ratings collected online are not part of this score.
    6.2 vs 7.4
  • 290 W higher power consumption
    This vacuum cleaner draws more power than the average vacuum cleaner (890 W vs 600 W).
    890 W vs 600 W
  • 6.3 in wider body
    This vacuum cleaner is wider than the average vacuum cleaner (16.7 in vs 10.4 in).
    16.7 in vs 10.4 in
  • 16.2% lower review score
    Reviews score
    6.2/ 10
    ✕
    What it is
    Average grade from independent test sites, magazines and video reviewers, 1–10.
    How we count it
    Grades: Each review's own score is converted to 1–10; without one, we grade the review ourselves. Big test sites count more, short reviews half as much as full tests. A video review counts half.
    Score: The average grade is 80% of the review mark; the number of reviews is the other 20% (1 review = 5, the typical number in this category = 8, the most-reviewed model = 10).
    Enough data: With few reviews, the average grade is pulled toward the typical grade of this category. No reviews yet: 7.6 for now.
    Share: Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
    Score distribution
    ▼
    <55-66-77-88-99-10

    6.2

    Mark 7.5 is below the typical mark 8.1 of this category, so it cannot lift the score above the technical score

    80%

    7.4

    Average grade

    20%

    8.2

    Popularity

    Grades by review (6)
    5 reviews: 1 with a printed score, 4 estimated from the review. 1 video review, counting half as much as a written test. Reviews count 25% of the overall score.
    User ratings collected online are not part of this score.
    6.2 vs 7.4
  • 4.8% worse value for money
    Miele Guard S1 offers worse value for money than the average vacuum cleaner (7.41 vs 7.8).
    7.41 vs 7.76
  • 65% more expensive
    Miele Guard S1 is more expensive than the average vacuum cleaner ($330 vs $200).
    $330 vs $200
  • No cyclonic technology
    This vacuum cleaner does not use cyclonic technology, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • 290 W higher power consumption
    This vacuum cleaner draws more power than the average vacuum cleaner (890 W vs 600 W).
    890 W vs 600 W
  • No bagless design
    This vacuum cleaner does not use a bagless design, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • No washable filter
    This vacuum cleaner does not include a washable filter, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • Lower filter class
    This vacuum cleaner uses a lower filter class than the average vacuum cleaner (airclean vs hepa).
    airclean vs hepa
  • No handheld conversion
    This vacuum cleaner does not have a 2-in-1 design, the average vacuum cleaner does.
  • 53.8% higher weight
    This vacuum cleaner is heavier than the average vacuum cleaner (12.3 lb vs 8 lb).
    12.3 lb vs 8 lb
  • 6.3 in wider body
    This vacuum cleaner is wider than the average vacuum cleaner (16.7 in vs 10.4 in).
    16.7 in vs 10.4 in

Video Reviews

Hands-on testing, unboxing, and real-world video evaluations

6.0
ibaisaic
≈ estimated
07/03/2025
Unboxing and first look · bag and filter check
Verdict
The Miele Guard S1 is solid and light, but the C2 Cat and Dog is the better buy for a small extra spend.
Shop video
Shop video
Shop video
Shop video
Shop video
Shop video
Hands-on video, no verdict

Expert Reviews

In-depth analysis and verdict from leading tech publications

7.0
spotlessreview.com
✓ explicit
7/11/2025
Expert review · Bagged cylinder
Verdict
The Miele Guard S1 is a sturdy bagged cleaner that picks up pet hair well and filters fine dust, but it is heavy to carry upstairs.
6.0
test-achats.be
≈ estimated
6/6/2027
Lab test · Bagged cylinder vacuum
Verdict
The Miele Guard S1 is an easy-to-use bagged vacuum with average cleaning results.
7.0
altroconsumo.it
≈ estimated
1/7/2026
Lab test · Light canister
Verdict
The Miele Guard S1 is a light bagged canister for daily use, with a 38 in telescopic tube, though its cleaning performance is only sufficient.
6.0
test-aankoop.be
≈ estimated
1/7/2025
Lab test · Bagged cylinder
Verdict
The Miele Guard S1 Flex is simple to handle, but its cleaning results are only average and the maker claims no HEPA exhaust filter.

Third-Party Reviews

What Customers Like About Miele Guard S1

  • Powerful suction performance across multiple power settings
  • Lightweight and compact design making it easy to carry and store
  • Highly maneuverable due to its smooth-rolling swivel casters
  • Quiet operation compared to many traditional barrel vacuums
  • Excellent AirClean filtration system retaining up to 99.99% of dust
  • Durable and reliable build quality consistent with the Miele brand

What Customers Don't Like About Miele Guard S1

  • High ongoing costs for replacement dust bags and filters
  • The standard floorhead struggles to pick up large debris on hard floors
  • Lacks internal storage for extra component attachments
  • Not well-suited for medium to high-pile carpets without buying a separate turbo brush
  • Smaller dust bag capacity limits extended cleaning sessions in larger homes
  • The power cord is shorter than on premium Miele models

Verdict

The Miele Guard S1 is a compact, entry-level bagged canister vacuum cleaner featuring an 890-watt PowerLine motor, a 3.7-quart HyClean Pure TU dustbag capacity, and an AirClean filtration system that retains 99.99% of fine dust. Weighing approximately 12.3 lb, it is highly maneuverable with its 3-point 360-degree swivel castors and offers a 33-foot operating radius with a 24.6-foot power cord and automatic rewind. Main pros include its exceptionally lightweight and space-saving build, strong suction performance on bare floors and flat rugs managed via a 4-stage rotary selector, and a durable EasySlide telescopic stainless steel wand. However, notable cons include its sub-optimal performance on plush carpets, a power cord that is shorter than previous Miele generations, and the requirement to bend down to adjust the suction dial rather than having handle-integrated or foot-activated controls.

Compare Miele Guard S1 With Other Vacuum Cleaners

1Product to compare no. 1
VS
2Product to compare no. 2
VS
3Product to compare no. 3 (optional)

Graphic Comparison of Miele Guard S1 and Other Vacuum Cleaners

No results found